The European Union’s flagship policy to restore damaged nature is hanging in the balance, with a vote to pass the law today cancelled after Hungary unexpectedly withdrew its support for the bill.
The vote, scheduled to take place at a meeting of EU countries’ environment ministers in Brussels, was called off after Hungary said it would no longer back the policy – wiping out the already-slim majority of countries in favour and leaving ministers struggling to decide their next steps.
The nature law is the latest EU environmental policy to come under fire as policymakers try to respond to months of angry farmers’ protests over complaints including strict green EU regulations.
The EU has already weakened numerous green rules to attempt to quell the protests.
“The agricultural sector is a very important sector, not only in Hungary, but everywhere in Europe,” Hungary’s state secretary for environment Anikó Raisz told reporters.
She said Hungary’s concerns included the costs.
Alain Maron, the Belgian environment minister who chaired the talks, said negotiations would continue but it was not clear what changes to the law could win over opponents.
“We don’t know exactly what are some reasons to be against this law for certain countries… it’s possible that they change their mind,” he told a press conference.
The law would be among the EU’s biggest environmental policies, requiring countries to introduce measures restoring nature on a fifth of their land and sea by 2030.
Cancelling a policy at this late stage of the EU’s legislative process is highly unusual.
Some EU diplomats said countries had already watered down the law during negotiations, and suggested Hunagry’s opposition was purely political, rather than over a specific policy issue.
EU environment commissioner Virginijus Sinkevičius said shelving the law would send a “disastrous signal” about the EU’s credibility, especially after the bloc pushed other countries in UN negotiations to back stronger targets to protect nature.
“We are fooling ourselves if we pretend that we can win our fight against climate change without nature,” Mr Sinkevičius said.
Opposed to it are Hungary, Italy, the Netherlands and Sweden. Austria, Belgium, Finland and Poland intend to abstain in the vote.
Any one of those eight countries changing position could allow the law to pass. The rest of the EU’s 27 member states support the policy.
Spanish climate minister Teresa Ribera said it would be a “huge irresponsibility” to reduce efforts to tackle worsening nature loss and climate change.
The law’s aim is to turn around the 81% of Europe’s natural habitats that are classed as in poor condition.
However, the policy has faced a backlash from some governments and politicians who are concerned it would impose burdensome rules on farmers, or clash with other industries.
